Iqbal Survé is said to be turning the press group into government lap-dog
Self-declared “gatvol” former employees of Independent Newspapers – now owned by the black-empowered fishing company Sekunjalo, headed by Dr Iqbal Survé – speculate that Survé has been “deployed” to transform the once-powerful Independent Group into a vehicle to promote government policy to the urban middle class.
Or, if that fails, to ultimately close down its titles, which are all seen as traditional mouthpieces for the (predominantly white) middle class and the opposition parties it supports. If not, they are at a loss to explain the purges, restructuring and “sheer lunacy” of the new management.
“In the meantime,” one senior staffer tells Noseweek, “he is paying himself R500,000 a month [as executive chairman].
He will be laughing at all of us for two or three years, living high on the hog and making Luthuli House [the ANC headquarters] happy while they pave his way for further sweetheart deals”.
“Maybe he’ll follow his friend Tina [Joemat-Petterssen] and get a posting to the board of the Nuclear Energy Corporation.”
Sekunjalo bought Independent Newspapers – with massive funding from the Public Investment Corproation (PIC) and Chinese investors – from the now-insolvent Sir Tony O’Reilly and his clan over a year ago.
![]() |
| The Emperor: Dr Iqbal Survé |
There is a general mood of paranoia at the newspapers in Cape Town, Johannesburg, Pretoria, Kimberley and Durban. After a string of firings and retrenchments of editors and senior staff, now even the sub-editors are up for the high-jump. The 102 permanent sub-editors employed at the various titles have all been asked to re-apply for their jobs. Word has it that just 72 will be reemployed and they will be required to accept at least a 10% pay cut.
No-one is entirely certain what will be the fate of the 30-or-so part-time sub-editors nationwide, but there’s “a mad scramble” going on to find jobs, any jobs, outside of the troubled company. “There is a general state of panic and fear in the building,” said one.
Despite promises that there would not be retrenchments under the new management and a promise to inject R1.5 billion into the “tech” operation, there has been blood on the floor of Independent Newspapers – including the The Star, Cape Times, Mercury, the Daily News, the Pretoria News, the Diamond Fields Advertiser, the Sunday Independent, Sunday Tribune and the Weekend Argus – for nearly a year.
It all started in December when Alide Dasnois, the Cape Times editor, was all-but marched out of the office after she carried a front page lead story about Sekunjalo’s rather shadowy association with the controversial R800m marine patrol ships tender (instead of carrying the story about Nelson Mandela’s death, which everyone in the world had already been told by the television and electronic media and despite an awardwinning Mandela wraparound cover).
Next to go was Chris Whitfield, editor-in-chief of Independent Newspapers in the Cape. He was offered a job to set up new operations in the Eastern Cape – a post several rungs down the corporate ladder – which he declined. So he, too, had effectively lost his job, but by resigning there was less of a media fuss than over Dasnois’s dismissal.
Then it was the turn of Terry Bell, author of the authoritative “Inside Labour” column in Business Report –the national daily finance newspaper carried in The Star, Cape Times, The Mercury and the Pretoria News. The first he knew that his column was to be chopped was when he read a tweet sent by a colleague.
Perhaps it wasn’t surprising that he was targeted because Bell had been seen as large as life outside Newspaper House in Cape Town on 19 December 2013 when the Right2Know Campaign held a picket protesting Dr Survé’s sudden dismissal of Dasnois. While Bell carefully didn’t mention Survé’s name, he did – speaking from the podium with R2K national co-ordinator Mark Weinberg – warn journalists that newspapers could be manipulated by owners. “I had the experience of working with some of these… for some of the biggest egomaniacs in the business, Tiny Rowland and Robert Maxwell.”
Bell’s colleague Donwald Pressly, Business Report bureau chief in Cape Town and author of the “Inside Parliament” column, was also seen in the crowd holding up a poster of Survé with a long Pinocchio nose. Pressly was suspended in January, after it was learned that he had tendered his name for inclusion on the DA’s parliamentary election list. (It was not included.) He was fired at the end of March. When he later won his case at the CCMA, he was retrenched “for operational requirements”.
The purge has continued in recent months. Business Report’s deputy editor Peter de Ionno, who had defended Pressly in his disciplinary hearing, was axed in late October. His former colleague Pressly sent out a tweet announcing that he had been axed after a drawn-out disciplinary process. De Ionno is challenging his dismissal at the CCMA.
Pressly also won’t divulge the details of his settlement because he signed a confidentiality agreement with the company.
While the dismissals, purges and retrenchments have focused on white journalists and editors, black editors Philani Mgwaba (The Mercury) Moshoeshoe Monare (Sunday Independent) and Makhudu Sefaro (The Star) have left of their own volition.
All three editors signed confidentiality agreements so can’t talk about their problems with Independent, but
Mgwaba was apparently outspoken about the fact that he was unwilling to undermine his credibility as a journalist by doing the bidding of Luthuli House (ANC headquarters).
Sefaro was pushed out after he refused to replace Mgwaba at The Mercury. He remains active in the South African National Editors’ Forum (where he is deputy chairman) although Independent have opted not to pay their R300 000 a year Forum membership fee. Monare has joined the Mail & Guardian. He too did not take calls, but it is understood that he refused to take orders from group editor Karima Brown and resigned.
The purge is set to continue. Reporters nationwide are to be served with Section 189 notices. They, like the sub-editors will have to re-apply for their jobs. One long-serving sub-editor Kenny Marshall – who was a wizard on financial stories, a rare skill – applied for the job vacated by Dave Chambers, the head of production.
Chambers left when it became clear that his temporary appointment would not be renewed. During his interview Marshall was asked various questions and he blurted out that he thought the present chairman of Independent (Iqbal Survé) was “objectionable”. He was hauled before a disciplinary and found guilty of “gross insubordination and insolence” and given a final written warning.
Other sub-editors who have left are Graeme Feltham, Laura Yeatman – who joined the Mail & Guardian – and Cape Times content editor (chief sub) Glenn Bownes. Chambers would not talk about his last days at Independent but it was widely known that he objected to the dividing up of the national production desk – where sub-editors edited all the publications of the group – to desks at individual titles (a system that O’Reilly had demolished). Ann Crotty, Business Report’s editor at large, left to join the Sunday Times.
Insiders say that after Pressly’s successful challenge of his dismissal – and likely success of Peter de Ionno’s challenge of his axing – the company has got wise. Dasnois is also challenging her dismissal at the labour court.
Indepdendent is now offering reporters and sub-editors the option of reapplying for their jobs and taking at least a 10 percent pay cut.
Meanwhile irate staff at the newspaper group have set up a website, The Daily (Soft) Survé, described as “A Tumblr devoted to hagiography/arse-licking of their new boss by INL papers”. The latest post is in August: “Sekunjalo steps in to rescue Sapa, the national press agency which is a section 21 company representing the major newspaper groups in South Africa.
Fortunately Survé’s attempts to take control of it – with a R50 million offer – came to naught. The site carries a “choice quote” from “Our Dear Leader”: “Apart from continuing the Sapa traditions of quality local content, the plan will be to expand the operation to become a major provider of content and other news services covering Africa.”
It adds a comment: “Perhaps with all that quality local content, there will be need for even fewer IOL journalists? Fortunately the management of Sapa did not allow Independent to buy it out, although Indy looks set to be a significant part of a collective of companies that will control a new private company controlling Sapa.”
In a New Year message to staff, the Emperor said: “There will be no large- scale retrenchments. None. Only bad performance will result in someone being asked to go. The days of cost-cutting are behind us. the days of cost-efficiencies, growth and development is [sic] part of our new lexicon.” ![]()
Yet by August, Section 189 notices were sent to all production staff.
It seems the process of turning one of the oldest independent news groups – which remained defiant during the apartheid era – is rapidly being transformed into a private sector Pravda.
Survé himself set the scene last December when he accused the rival Times Media Group of a dirty-tricks campaign aimed at robbing his group of revenue and readers. Times Media had tried in vain, said Survé, to get control of Independent Newspapers, and had tried to portray him as “a crooked businessman and ANC lackey” who wanted to counter negative reporting of the ruling party.
Only he, Survé, has used exactly those words.


3 replies on “Fishy whiff at Independent”
It is my humble opinion that rarely do reporters, independent or otherwise, reach to the heart of a story, this one included. The real questions to be asked are WHO is behind the people and groups that effect control of mainstream media – both here and beyond our borders – and WHY. WHAT exactly is the agenda that they are seeking to push through the media [what is the common denominator that links them?] and HOW else are they seeking to manipulate the thought & opinion of the general public. There is a much bigger picture that SA journalists either ignore or for some reason refuse to touch. Internationally, independent journalists are addressing issues of unipolar global dominance and the various agendas that are being driven to achieve this goal, whilst in SA – where many of these programmes are being implemented – the silence is deafening. Can it really be that our dumbed down education system has worked so well that everybody is completely ignorant of the biggest issue of this century? Or are those in the know just too dumb to care?
Here we go ….
It appears obvious to me that pro-ANC business men will now continue on this path and muzzle the opposition press that so valiantly fought on their behalf for many years before 1994.
Seems we are well on the way of becoming like Nigeria and other corrupt regimes across the continent – the dream of a Rainbow nation sadly fades away …..
crooked ? Lackey ? Big words to describe scum.