UPDATE: Evershed's default and send in heavies

Pity Ursula Smith, the legal secretary who had the temerity to take on her former employer, giant legal firm Eversheds (noses133,136). In nose136 it was reported that Ursula (a nom de guerre) was awarded R78,000 by the CCMA in a “default judgment” after complaining of constructive dismissal. Eversheds had failed to turn up for the November 8 hearing.

However, Eversheds failed to pay up by the deadline of December 15. Then, in February, Ursula received a curt SMS from the CCMA instructing her to attend a new arbitration hearing on March 4. It emerged that the law firm had protested the R78,000 award, claiming they had not received notice of the November hearing – despite a fax advice noted in Ursula’s file.

The CCMA accepted this explanation, obediently rescinded its default award and ordered Ursula’s claim be heard again.

At the March 4 hearing, Eversheds appeared in force in the form of deputy chairman Lavery Modise and Ursula’s nemesis, HR director Nikki Webb.

There was another delay: Eversheds said its senior labour lawyer, Imraan Mahomed, who would lead evidence for the firm, required two full days to cross-examine Ursula, and would be calling six witnesses.

In order to give the great labour lawyer time to prepare for his epic clash with poor Ursula, the arbitration was postponed to May 3 and 4. (Big law firms are adept at creating delays that wear down adversaries and deplete their fighting funds – and spirit.)

Meanwhile Ursula, who has a daughter in matric, has been struggling to find work and faces eviction from her rented home.

Share this article:

Reader's comments

Like to add your own comment ? Please click here to subscribe - OR -
Submitted by : Fabrizio Merlo on 2011-04-17 19:36:21
Eversheds is a disgrace and a bunch of vindictive cowards. If you add up the cost of this appeal by culculating their hourly chargeout I am sure it comes to more than the paltry 78 000.00 award. I hope these partners feel good when they get into their Mercs and beamers while the woman is about to be evicted .

What goes round comes round they should remember.


While every reasonable effort is taken to ensure the accuracy and soundness of the contents of this publication, neither the authors nor the publishers of this website bear any responsibility for the consequences of any actions based on the information contained therein.

Important information regarding cookies
By using this website, you consent to the use of cookies in accordance with our Privacy Policy.