What to make of the Sunday Times Mbeki bribe story ..

The R30m allegedly paid to President Mbeki in relation to the R8-billion German submarine contract -- as reported in the Sunday Times -- can only have been a small part of the commissions/bribes paid to various parties in relation to that contract.

Consider this: British investigators have estimated that BAe's representatives in South Africa, Richard Charter (who died not long thereafter while canoeing on the Orange River) and Basil Hersov (who can't remember who he distributed the money to) were involved in laundering an estimated R1.8-billion in “commission” within weeks of the aircraft deals being signed in 1999.

And what of the strange changes in the corvette bids -- and the French connection involving Mbeki's visits to and from the directors of Thompsons -- later Thales, now Thint – the ones he had so conveniently forgotten about? And then there were those fateful words attributed to Tony Yengeni -- and never denied -- as he secretly rallied the forces in December 2000 to close down the arms deal investigations that were to have been launched by parliament's select committee on public accounts (SCOPA): "I and others have money in our bank accounts that we can't explain. I don't intend to explain it to anyone, either. We deserve it."

A few things emerge from all of this: Firstly, the ANC has a problem: the vast majority of its supporters cannot afford food, let alone fund a political party. So to fund its infrastructure and campaigns, the party has had to look to funders it would rather not identify.

Who demand their pound of flesh in profit or policy changes.

That way we end up paying R50-billion-plus for inappropriate defence equipment in order to provide the party with perhaps half a billion in funding. (Assuming the other half billion-plus went to the suits.)

Surely there are more rational – and less corrupting – ways of funding the democratic process? As we have suggested before: taxpayers would surely rather have paid the party R1 billion directly as, say, a statutory election allowance -- and kept the other R49 billion in change.

Then there's the prosecution of Jacob Zuma: in the light of the latest developments, it does look increasingly like it's been used as a red herring -- most successfully up till now -- to distract the media and the public from the bigger unhappy picture. I don't raise this in defence of Zuma: It’s natural for politicians to use any dirt that comes to hand against their competitors. It’s also the way democracy gets to benefit; as the saying goes: when thieves fall out the truth will likely out, too.

But there is potential for even greater benefit in what might otherwise look like a situation dangerously out of control: The NPA should offer both Mbeki and Zuma indemnity from prosecution – in exchange for their evidence to prosecute the corruptors. If it is proven the deals were corruptly achieved, they could be held to be invalid, absolving South Africa of the appalling debt. (We might have to return the equipment -- which we didn't need or want anyway.) The criminal suppliers and their political sponsors in Europe would be taught a lesson they won't quickly forget. Both Mbeki and Zuma could redeem themselves with one stroke and still go down in history as (fallible men) who did great things for their country. -- The Editor

Quotes to remember:
‘You cannot survive without bribing an official in South Africa.’ -- Essop Pahad, minister in charge of the president’s office.

‘Sitting in government there are sophisticated thieves continually seeking ways to misdirect public resources away from the people to themselves.’ -- President Thabo Mbeki.

Arms Deal
Richard Charter
Basil Hersov
Thabo Mbeki
Essop Pahad
submarine contract
Share this article:

Reader's comments

Like to add your own comment ? Please click here to subscribe - OR -
Submitted by : Anthony Krijger of Westville on 2008-08-13 13:03:40
Unfortunately the same attitude has led to the demise of countries like Zimbabwe and Uganda in the 70's.

Bob Mugabe has used his countries money supply as his (and his cronies) personal piggy bank. The plunder continued until there was no money left. the simple answer was merely to print more money, and more and more until the money became worthless.

Africa should be the richest continent on the planet. Look at the mines in Congo, oil in Libya, Nigeria, Sudan and Angola and just what these countries alone produce should be enough to turn the whole of Africa into a gigantic Switzerland. However, their people remain the poorest in the world. And this is all due to the greed of our fellow men.
Submitted by : Craig Thom of CHEMPET on 2008-08-12 11:54:35
That's the best suggestion I have heard.
Unfortunately two great obstacles are in the way, Mbeki & Zuma's pride/ego. They don't want to admit they are thieves, just like Boesak and all the others before them.
The sickening thing is that as taxpayers or citizens, we are toothless.
Unless someone out there has a great plan to make these people accountable.


While every reasonable effort is taken to ensure the accuracy and soundness of the contents of this publication, neither the authors nor the publishers of this website bear any responsibility for the consequences of any actions based on the information contained therein.